Sunday, June 21, 2009

Sidewalks, speed bumps and trash (Two of three!)

There are more pedestrian fatalities in Bangalore (and probably in India, but I don't have figures for the whole country) than vehicular fatalities. I find that very interesting. It's a good argument for being in/on a vehicle instead of traveling by foot.

Part of this is that sidewalks are pretty much nonexistent. From what I can gather, there were lots of sidewalks in Bangalore twenty years ago. Bangalore was known as "The Garden City," and there were lots of parks, lakes, and green areas around the city. Kind of an Indian version of Minneapolis.

But with the technology boom of the last ten years or so, a complete lack of any kind of zoning laws and no eminent domain laws, private developers have bought much of the green space and the government has sold most of the parks and lakes, all for development. There were about 30 lakes around the city twenty years ago; now there are four. They've been filled in with dirt and garbage, covered over completely, and there are now office buildings and subdivisions where there used to be green areas. Palm Meadows, the subdivision where we live, used to be a swamp.

The government doesn't have the resources (financial or administrative) to handle the increased need for infrastructure to manage or control all of this, so it's really become an "anything goes" kind of atmosphere. Particularly if you bribe the right folks, unfortunately.

The number of vehicles on Bangalore streets has multiplied by a factor of ten in the last ten years. Imagine that happening in Minneapolis, and you can start to imagine what the traffic conditions are like here. City streets are widened to accommodate the increased traffic by taking the area on either side of the street, which was (you guessed it!) ... the sidewalks. Now there are just terribly narrow dirt paths along the sides of most Bangalore streets. These are maybe 2-3 feet wide, and there is a big dropoff from the road to this narrow dirt shoulder, so if you get your tires ("tyres," here) off the shoulder, you may tear the bottom out of your car.

Just beside these narrow dirt pathway/street shoulders are the buildings and businesses. Pedestrians scoot along from shop to shop staying very close to the buildings. Small children play alongside traffic (they're either far calmer than my children, or more obedient. There's definitely a Darwinian attitude here about leaving your children outside the shop to play next to traffic).

Because there are no eminent domain laws, the government can't force the business or homeowners whose buildings border on the street to sell their buildings for additional road construction or to build sidewalks. India is the world's biggest democracy, and freedom here is prized very highly. But many Indians tend to be short-sighted, and they would rather not give up the freedom to keep their own business in order to insure there is safe infrastructure for everyone.

That's one of the most interesting adjustments to Indian mindsets that I've found, and one of the most difficult for me to adjust to. There is very much a "me first" attitude, and most people have no real sense of "looking out for the team."

There are, of course, exceptions. But between the greed and corruption that tends to exist with elected officials and the "me first" attitude of lots of business people and landowners, it's going to be very difficult for India to bring its cities to a safer, more pedestrian (frankly, more HUMAN) friendly standard.

One of the things I've grown somewhat accustomed to (although it still drives me nuts) is the proliferation of speed bumps. They're everywhere here. You'll be driving down a major highway, getting your speed up to maybe 40 mph (which is very fast for Bangalore), and all of a sudden there's a speed bump. If you have a good driver they anticipate these and brake almost to a stop, creep over them to avoid damaging your car, then resume their speed. About 3/4 of a mile later, there's another speed bump. This isn't because there's a congested business district and traffic needs to slow for pedestrian safety. These things are everywhere - on the highways as well as in residential areas.

The one thing that still freaks me out without fail, though, is the garbage. There is no regular garbage pickup in Bangalore (and I would suspect this is true in all of India). Most people don't have the money to pay for it, and for generations they've just dumped it wherever ... so it would require a huge shift in attitudes (and pocketbooks) to make a meaningful change.

The areas that DO have garbage pickup (like Palm Meadows) have a contract with a garbage hauler. These contracts usually just stipulate that the garbage hauler will take the trash outside the city limits. It doesn't have to be dumped in any kind of EPA-approved landfill (because there aren't any). Waste from hospitals is included in this. Much of this garbage is sewage-soaked. The garbage haulers take the garbage just outside the city limits and dump it on the first vacant lot they find.

In today's newspaper there's a story about a group of parents who have pooled their financial resources to pay to have a garbage dump covered over, because the vacant lot where it's located is 15 feet from their children's school. The school, which goes from nursery/preschool age to third grade, had not been able to let the children play on the playground because the fumes from the garbage adjacent to the school made the children vomit.

The parents got together and approached the police (there are laws against this kind of dumping, but they're rarely enforced), the local government officials, etc. -- but nothing was done. So they hired excavators to dig a trench, pull the garbage into the trench and cover it up. There's nothing to keep the garbage haulers from just dumping right on top of it again, and all of that waste, including the untreated hospital waste, just goes right into the ground (and, one presumes, the groundwater).

Yep, we all drink bottled water in India. We don't eat anything that isn't peeled, and I buy only organic if I can find it. Of course, there's no regulation over what can be labeled as "organic," so it's still a shot in the dark.

Don't get me wrong. I really do like it here, and I'm enjoying our time. I needed to break out of my sheltered, Minnesotan-attitude of "yep, I pay my taxes and everything's kept clean and pretty." It's been really eye-opening to see how playground equipment is rusted and incredibly dangerous - and the kids still play on it and laugh and seem perfectly happy, since they don't have any frame of reference. (Not MY kids, however.) The weather is spectacular now that the hot part of the summer is over, and overall, people are very friendly and helpful. (As long as you stay out of the Hero Honda dealerships....see prior blog entry.)

I try to imagine sometimes what "real" Indians would think if they came to the US. People like our driver, Giri, who have never traveled outside India. His uncle lives in New Jersey and works for a technology company, and Giri tells me that his uncle doesn't like coming back to India, even for family weddings and events because he loves America so much.

Still, it's surprising how many Indians who have lived abroad come back to India to live permanently. I can't imagine leaving the US permanently, and a good bit of what sanity I have is tied to knowing that I'll be coming back. But then again, the US/UK are kind of the standard that much of the world aspires to.

I didn't appreciate that fully before. I'm not sure I'll take it for granted again.

2 comments:

Nancy Schuneman said...

I just love these blogs. They're humorous and informative. It's fun to follow along and read about all of your experiences in India.Have a good trip home next week.

Nancy

Gem said...

Hey I got a mention! And I only just got to read that I got a mention! I'm disappointed you didn't drop the bomb, but I understand why lol!

:)