Friday, March 6, 2009

Am I the only one?

Am I the only one who is annoyed by news reports that state the painfully obvious, as though it's some major breakthrough discovery that required in-depth research and behind-the-scenes contacts? On the CNN website today, there's the following headline: "Bus Beheading Suspect Ruled Mentally Ill." You may remember the horrific story - back in the summer of 2008, on a Greyhound bus traveling across Canada, a man freaked out and started stabbing the young man sitting next to him - a total stranger who was asleep at the time. The rest of the passengers got off the bus - the driver and a few passengers tried to get back on the bus to see if the stabbing victim was still alive, and they saw that he was likely already dead, and was being decapitated with a large kitchen knife. And the judge has decided that the perpetrator is mentally ill. Ummmmm ... and your first clue was .....? And it's reported like this is, well --- news.

It happens a LOT in Indian newspapers. Along with just plain weird wording (and I'm not talking about the Anglicized versions of things - but odd word choices that make it clear that English may not be the reporter's first language).

Here's an example. In today's Times of India, there's a headline that reads: "Elderly Anganwadi Workers Are At the Receiving End of Government Apathy."

How is one on the receiving end of apathy? Wouldn't you be on the non-receiving end of apathy? What is it you're receiving, when you're receiving apathy?

(FYI, anganwadi workers are generally women from lower socioeconomic groups, who are usually the sole breadwinners in their families. They are government employees who are a combination of census taker, social worker and nurse. They immunize infants and children, make sure government social programs are being distributed to those most in need, etc.)

Here's another one - page 5. "Stop Atrocities on Women: NGO." (An NGO is a non-government organization, usually a not-for-profit.) But coming out and making such a risky, subversive statement as "stop atrocities on women." Wow. Deserving of a headline.

And then there's the story of the Bollywood actor, Sanjay Dutt, who was convicted of violating the Arms Act in the 1993 Mumbai attacks. He was sentenced to six years in prison, but is out on bail pending an appeal. Indian elections are coming up, and Mr Dutt is in the news because he wants a stay on his conviction ... so he can run for national public office.

WHAT?!?!?!

His argument is, if he's not granted a stay, it will irreparably harm his political career. To say nothing of the bind it might put on continuing the terrorist activity he was convicted of.

And people wonder why Indian politics is so corrupt.

In India, convicted felons can run for public office six years after they have completed their prison term. Not sure why six is the magic number. Seven is right out. (Greg and Fred are probably the only ones who will get *that* reference.)

In other "news of India," the entire bar association of the High Court in Chennai (formerly Madras) is on strike. They've only appeared in court 9 days so far in 2009. It's not terribly clear what all their gripes are, but it appears that a big part (if not the biggest part) of what they're trying to achieve is a sweeping set of changes in the criminal code. Now it looks like the India Supreme Court is evidently considering permanently disbarring all the attorneys who aren't back in the courtroom within the next week.

See why I look forward to the newspapers?!?

1 comment:

Unknown said...

Happy Birthday, Vicki! Judy sent me the link to your blog. I've just read the last few entries. Sounds like you're having a roaring great time in India. Well, you're having a time, anyway. Hope your birthday is fun. I'm sure it's going to be different!
Barbara